Like most people, there are some experiences in life I usually try to avoid. Most of the time it’s part of an aversion to some sort of discomfort, usually phusical or psychological. Then there are those aversions which are completely irrational and get their own category:
I call one of them, “Brooklyn.”
I can’t really explain why I get so unnerved in Brooklyn. It could be the multi-million dollar mansions situated in anotherwise aesthetically depressed area, or the overwhelming particular Jewisness of the area one that can only be circularly defined as “Brooklyn.”
Still, all fears must be confronted at some point so yesterday I joined my mother and grandparents on a little errand running excursion to Coney and J. The thinking was that while the rest of New York would be shut down – I can’t remember crusing down the West Side Highway that quickly in midday – Brooklyn would be running along as usual. I didn’t break out into hives or start convulsing, but there were definately some notable Brooklyn highlights:
- I was in Eichlers and overheard a father and mother (different families) with respective children recently engaged (not to each other) were comparing notes on wedding preperations (ketuvah, “backup tenaim,” etc). In the course of their conversation, the woman complimented the man’s tie. In the spirit of holiday, the man replied, “You like the tie? It’s yours. I can get these for $5.” and proceeded to take off his tie, puts it on the counter, and gives it to the dumbfounded woman.
- Waiting for my mother and grandmother in one of the Brooklyn dress shops, I noticed that the background music was not only sung by female, but the song was “White Christmas.” I can excuse the vocalist because the only men who would enter the store would presumably already be beyond saving. But regarding the song choice, perhaps they consider it Jewish Music after all.
- Someone behind the counter of a pizza shop called over a teenager and asked him if he was new in town. The teen said yes and asked how he knew. The man said it was because he noticed that every time the teen got up from a table someone else came and took it, adding with a smile, “you’ve got to be more careful around here – don’t be so trusting.”
- And finally there was this priceless exchange at the same pizza store with an obviously appreciative customer:
“God bless Christmas”
“Yeah, only a Yid could pull this off.”
You know, I may need to take Brooklyn off the list.
Maybe just for Christmas anyway.
bagel’s and co (77th and york) was playing christmas carols too (i remember that it was something distinctly christological), and nobody seemed to notice. the person i was with burst out laughing and said “welcome to america”.
Last year on December 25, we took our daughter to the Jewish Children’s Museum in Crown Heights. I must say, there was absolutely no sign of Christmas whatsoever for blocks around. There were plenty of handbills posted about a Hey Teves fabrengen, though.
One of your best posts ever!
in the immortal words of Lil Kim,
better have a pass when you cross that bridge
welcome to Brooklyn
I have spent many an hour contemplating the nature of Brooklyn and why it bothers me so much. I can fill a page with Brooklyn stories and if you categorize the examples above most of my stories would fall under one of the categories above (except you missed the two worst kind of Brooklyn Experiences: self-righteous rudeness and driving associated happenings) but if you distill the stories (“symptoms” of the disease) what you find is one common thread that explains why I despise Brooklyn:
I believe that the story of the Orthodox world in the 20th century is a story of how to engage the modern world. Walk into williamsburg and you feel like you are in hungary circa 1900. For this example, lets put KJ on the other end of the spectrum. The problem is that Brooklyn doesnt lie on the williamsburg/KJ spectrum. Instead they have chosen certain elements of modern society to accept….the very worst elements. In choosing to accept all the worst that the modern world has to offer, Brooklyn has sold its soul.