Jewish: October 2004 Archives

October 26, 2004

If you're reading this blog, odds are you've read something about Jewish Law. You might have seen one of the many codifications such as the Mishnah Torah or Shulhan Aruch. Perhaps you've come across a commentary on one of these codes, common ones being the Ramo or Mishnah Berurah. You may have even read published rabbinic teshuvot - responsa addressing specific questions - like Yehaveh Da'at by R. Ovadia Yosef or the Iggros Moshe by R. Moshe Feinstein. Contemporary publishers such as Feldheim or Artscroll compile popular positions of Jewish Law on selected topics. All these works contain Rabbis' opinions, rulings, and occasionally reasonings for their halakhic decisions. In all of these works, the Rabbinic writers intend to shape Jewish practice - albeit to different degrees depending on the intended audience and the intended effect of their decisions.

If you've seen these types of sources, you're also probably aware that for any given issue, there are multiple opinions. Considering all the halakhic debates, it's hard enough deciding whom to follow, let alone making a decision for other people. Each posek has his own methodologies for reaching his conclusions, and to fully understand each one requires a complete and detailed study of their individual works. However, all "poskim" share similar challenges in publishing their works. One such challenge is distinguishing normative Jewish Law with statements of public policy.



October 23, 2004

I've always had an odd relationship with NCSY. I was chapter president of Springfield for 4 years - 2 Junior and 2 Senior - but that was mostly because there was no one else around my age to do the job. At the shabbatons themselves I found myself somewhat marginailzed, due to a combination of adolescent awkwardness (read: geek) and having an alternative hashkafa which emphasized independent thought.

This past shabbat there was a Senior NCSY shabbaton in Springfield. An old friend my high school NCSY days, is now the regional director of some sort - despite swearing repeatedly that, "I am *never* doing NCSY when I graduate." Aside from him, I knew a maximum of four other people who were involved with the shabbaton.

Anyway, it got me thinking back to my days as an NCSY'er. Since I'm home, I dug up a poem I wrote for the yearbook.

This was my last year in NCSY. I was outgoing Sr. President of Springfield, and my sister Esther was advisor of Juniors at the time. The Etz Chaim region has a thing called the "Torah Fund," where they hit up the chapters for arbitrarily assessed amounts - loosely based on membership. This money went to the usual causes of supporting students for Israel programs and getting nice things for administrator's families.

Fortunately, a chapter could fulfill its requirement by purchasing ads in the yearbook, and Springfield's was so low that we were able to cover it by getting two ads. Esther and I decided to split one of them for Juniors and Seniors and I knocked out the following poem in roughly 15 minutes (she can vouch for that).

One editor of the yearbook was so offended by it she almost didn't let it get published. In the end, she let it go through, but only after she mangled the meter on most stanzas. I don't care enough to fix it right now, so you'll have to deal with someone else's horrible editing of a high-school senior's 15 minute poem.

I present, now with additional annotations,


The NCSY Shabbaton Experience





Meta-YUTOPIA

Valid XHTML 1.0!    Valid CSS!

Site Meter

XML  RSS
ATOM
J-Blogosphere
JRants
Judaism Blogs - Blog Catalog Blog Directory
Blog Directory

Creative Commons License
This blog is licensed under a
Creative Commons License.

Listed on BlogShares

This website is powered by
Movable Type